This Proxy War Can’t Be Both ‘Unprovoked’ AND A Great Strategic Investment

If you accept that this war is a very low-cost, high-reward means for the US to advance its strategic interests overseas, then you’d have to have tapioca for brains to also believe that the US wouldn’t have gone out of its way to make sure the war happens.

By Caitlin Johnstone

October 03, 2023 – Information Clearing House As opposition to funding the US proxy war in Ukraine increases on Capitol Hill, empire apologists have been frantically churning out think pieces about how much the war serves US strategic interests in order to manufacture support for its continued backing by Washington. Such arguments flatly contradict the propaganda messaging we were inundated with at the beginning of the war that this was an “unprovoked invasion”, but empire managers don’t seem particularly interested in defending that narrative anymore.

The latest appearance in this new “our Ukraine proxy warfare greatly advances US strategic interests” genre of op-ed comes to us courtesy of notorious war propagandist Max Boot via The Washington Post. Boot’s article was originally titled “Ukraine aid is a great investment. Don’t let MAGA Republicans end it.”, but the headline has since been revised to the slightly less creepy “This is what the U.S. is getting by aiding Ukraine.” 

Claiming that funding the war is “the right thing to do strategically,” Boot argues that “it is hard to think of any U.S. foreign policy initiative since the end of the Cold War that has been more successful or more important than U.S. aid to Ukraine.”

“Russia has lost an estimated 120,000 soldiers and 170,000 to 180,000 have been injured,” Boot writes. “Russia has also lost an estimated 2,329 tanks, 2,817 infantry fighting vehicles, 2,868 trucks and jeeps, 354 armored personnel carriers, 538 self-propelled artillery vehicles, 310 towed artillery pieces, 92 fixed-wing aircraft and 106 helicopters.”

“The Russian armed forces have been devastated, thereby reducing the risk to front-line NATO states such as Poland and the Baltic republics that the United States is treaty-bound to protect,” Boot continues. “And all of that has been accomplished without having to put a single U.S. soldier at risk on the front lines.”

“That’s an incredible investment,” gloats Boot.

At no time in his masturbatory gushing about how many Russians this war has helped kill does Boot make any mention of the immense toll this deliberately provoked and completely unnecessary war has taken on Ukrainian lives. Their deaths and dismemberments and displacement are the largest price being paid into this “investment” by far, but Boot doesn’t deem them worthy of even a footnote.

We’ve been seeing this “investment” line being promoted with increasing frequency by US empire managers and their apologists. In an article published in the Connecticut Post last month, Senator Richard Blumenthal assured Americans that “we’re getting our money’s worth on our Ukraine investment.” A few days prior to that Senator Mitt Romney had described the proxy war as “the best national defense spending I think we’ve ever done,” because “We’re diminishing and devastating the Russian military for a very small amount of money… a weakened Russia is a good thing.” In December Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell said that funding the proxy war is “a direct investment in reducing Vladimir Putin’s future capabilities to menace America, threaten our allies and contest our core interests.” Last November the imperial war machine-funded think tank Center for European Policy Analysis published a report arguing that “US spending of 5.6% of its defense budget to destroy nearly half of Russia’s conventional military capability seems like an absolutely incredible investment.”

We saw one of the most glaring examples of this new genre of empire apologia last week, when the Bill Kristol-led group “Republicans for Ukraine” put out a television ad explaining how much this war is a fantastic investment which serves US strategic interests.

“When America arms Ukraine, we get a lot for a little,” the ad said. “Putin is an enemy of America. We’ve used 5% of our defense budget to arm Ukraine, and with it, they’ve destroyed 50% of Putin’s Army. We’ve done all this by sending weapons from storage, not our troops. The more Ukraine weakens Russia, the more it also weakens Russia’s closest ally, China.”

We are asked to believe a lot of very stupid things by the propagandists of the US-centralized empire, but one of the very stupidest is the claim that this war simultaneously (A) was completely unprovoked, and (B) just coincidentally happens to massively advance US strategic interests.

It really cannot be both. If you accept that this war is a very low-cost, high-reward means for the US to advance its strategic interests overseas, then you’d have to have tapioca for brains to also believe that the US wouldn’t have gone out of its way to make sure the war happens. And indeed that’s exactly what occurred, which is why US intelligence operatives and western foreign policy analysts spent years saying that the actions of the US and its allies were going to provoke Russia to war.

The reason it matters so much that the war in Ukraine was provoked by the US-centralized empire is because that shows you where the path to peace lies. When empire simps object to criticisms of western proxy warfare in Ukraine with “Oh so you’re saying we should just ABANDON THE UKRAINIANS and let Putin take over the country???”, what they are missing is that this is not a war between only Russia and Ukraine, and Russia doesn’t see it as such. Russia believes it is fighting a war against the aggression and expansionism of the NATO alliance, which the head of NATO himself recently confirmed. What this means is that the NATO alliance can facilitate peace in Ukraine by agreeing to roll back the aggressions which led to this war in the first place. 

NATO powers have always been fully aware that they could bring about peace in Ukraine in this way, but they choose not to move NATO war machinery away from Russia’s borders and grant Moscow the same freedom from military threats in its immediate surroundings that Washington insists on in its own immediate surroundings. The managers of the empire chose not to do this, and indeed actually sabotaged peace negotiations in the early days of the conflict, because they firmly believe that this war advances their interests.

This is what empire apologists are omitting from the story when they claim that Putin can end this war by withdrawing troops from Ukraine; they are leaving out their own government’s role in starting and perpetuating this war. To demand that Russia cease its aggressions, without the western empire ceasing the aggressions which provoked the war in the first place, is to demand that Russia lie down and submit itself to the dictates of the empire. People who call for an end to Russian aggressions but not the western aggressions Russia is reacting to don’t really want peace, they just want the empire to conquer and subjugate the insolent curs who dared to defy it.

It’s good to be clear on this, because it shows who the obstacles to peace really are. The longer we pretend the only people keeping this war going reside in Moscow, the longer any path toward peace will elude us.

Caitlin’s articles are entirely reader-supported, so if you enjoyed this piece please consider sharing it around, liking her on Facebook, following her antics on Twitter, checking out herpodcast, throwing some money into her hat on PatreonorPaypal, or buying her book Woke: A Field Guide for Utopia Preppers. New book! Lao Sue And Other Poems, available in paperback or PDF/ebook. – All works co-authored with her husband Tim Foley.

Click Here To Get Our FREE Newsletter

ICH: Free for those who can’t afford it. Supported by those who can.

Not For Profit – For Global Justice – Since 2001

Please help Independent Media

Views expressed in this article are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of Information Clearing House.





11 responses to “This Proxy War Can’t Be Both ‘Unprovoked’ AND A Great Strategic Investment”

  1. Woopy Avatar

    The Ukraine debacle is just another Zionist war against humanity plus the Zionists have believed that Russia belongs to the Zionists ever since Stalin kicked them out of power. The cold war was begun because Zionists wanted Russia. At the end of the cold war the Zionists, and others, were major carpet baggers taking Russian properties until Putin became president and changed things. However that didn’t stop the Zionists who fought Russia with propaganda, sanctions/tariffs for 20 years until their cookie gi Victoria Nuland along with John McCain and Lindsey Graham began the proxy war against Russia. Of course our congressmen went in lockstep with the war knowing if they didn’t becoming reelected in their cush jobs would be tough at the least.

    1. abraham Weizfeld PhD Avatar

      Woopy should be expelled due to ouvert Antisemitism. Even the examples of Zionist agents are all not Jewish but rather agents of the USA State Empire.

      1. Woopy Avatar

        PhD the truth must hurt you. Hopefully you are aware that their are probably more Evangelical Zionists in the US than white supremist Jews. Most of the Jews in the US and Israel are not “Semitic” Jews nor are the white supremist Jews of Israel Semitic Jews. You need to do some research.

      2. braithwa842 Avatar

        Lindsey Graham? Yes, not Jew. Just a proud self declared Zionist.

      3. braithwa842 Avatar

        Censorship is always wrong. But tell me: Do you support Blinken, Nuland, Kagan, Kristol, Perl, Frum, et al ?

    2. Prometheus Avatar

      Zionism is just one front-of-house operation of the WA$P puppeteers.
      The Hydra has many heads.

  2. Woopy Avatar

    As this is written the white supremist Jews of Israel are bombing Syria, intimidating Iran, and murdering Palestinians. The white supremist Jews of Israel believe that their superiority gives them the right to murder, steal land and lie about.

  3. Disadvantaged Avatar

    The videos shows that the Republicans can misrepresent the facts just as much as the Democrats. The incompetency by so many in Washington D.C. is greater than ever. Look at all the major positions occupied by those of the Jewish faith. This has been going on for many decades. Just do a little research. The truth is out there!

    You cannot trust anyone in Washington. That in itself, indicates that America will fail.

  4. doug Avatar

    It is all about war profiteers and war mongers like Jens Stoltenberg and John Bolton who have a twisted belief  that all the worlds problems can solved by state sponsored terrorism via  military aggression.

    1. Nina Sakun Avatar
      Nina Sakun

      definitely wars are not started by invading smaller weaker neighbors. it is somebody else’s fault that putin couldn’t invade simply and cleanly. why couldn’t the ukrainians just give up right away? the war clearly is their fault and those who are helping them. it is so simple. but the war profiteers keep saying it is putin’s and russia’s fault when russia just wanted to take over ukraine without any real war. just a little special operation is what they wanted. poor russian victims of evil nato

  5. doug Avatar

    The people who start these wars or croon about what a good deal it is to kill so many people at relatively low financial cost will never spend one second in a trench or on the frontlines fighting for their own causes, including NATO.